I already have a BMW X1 Xline l would have gone for the 3 series this time just for a change but have now decided to get another X1 because as Glos Guy says it’s about the best on the scheme at the moment
To add some balance George, as everyone’s views are always subjective and tinged with some bias towards brands we like (or away from brands we don’t like or yearn for), I would say that the X1 isn’t in the same league as the 3 series. For that matter, the 3 series isn’t in the same league as the 5 Series. I’ve had quite a few 3’s and 5’s, so can speak from experience!
The consensus of the motoring press would probably be that the X1 is beaten overall by the Volvo XC40. The Volvo is a newer generation car with more up to date tech, is quieter and whereas the X1 is looking a bit dated now, the Volvo is a bit more modern. However, the same consensus view is that the X1 is the better drivers car and BMW’s iDrive is far superior to the ‘touch screen for everything’ approach taken by Volvo. XC40 owners on this forum seem to report poor mpg and seat comfort issues on the Inscription Pro. Having read and watched dozens of reviews on the X1 (stand alone and group tests) I made a list of the positives and negatives to help me decide. Listed below;
Negatives
– Excessive tyre noise over 70mph (worse with largest wheel sizes)
– Suspension quite stiff
– Seats are small and lack under thigh support
Positives
– Good to drive
– Handles more like a hatchback than an SUV
– “Most driver focussed car in the small premium SUV class”
– Smooth auto gearbox
– “xDrive offers immense grip when cornering”
– “2.0i is a quick car”
– Surprisingly spacious and practical
– “As classy inside as family SUV’s get”
– Standard seats have good side support
– Dashboard controls laid out in logical manner
– Good forward visibility
– “Infotainment system best in family SUV class”
– Flush boot lip helps loading
As a current owner George, how close to the mark would you say this summary is?