We aren’t due to change until next July (order in April) and every quarter I go through the new lists in detail and make a shortlist of what interests me. Sadly, the list seems to get shorter every quarter and whilst there are a few cars that ‘might do’, there is nothing that I would really ‘want’ or desire!
I don’t want an EV (which seems to be all that Motability are focussing on these days) but would consider a PHEV, although I know that these are a compromise. Don’t really fancy (or need) a diesel, so another petrol is the most likely choice.
Similar to you, there is nothing on the scheme that comes even remotely close to our current BMW X1 2.0i 4WD, so any change would feel like a step down. I’m not a fan of lease extensions as I think they are a rip off and make the whole life cost of leasing the car more than if I’d bought the damned thing, but if I thought that scheme choice was starting to improve I might extend in the knowledge that I could order the minute that something good came on, but there’s no sign of that direction of travel yet (EV’s excepted), so I might bite the bullet and leave the scheme and go down the private route. I am fortunate that I can consider this option and I would get something that’s never going to be on the scheme, so wouldn’t be making comparisons!
I would prefer to stay with Motability as it’s easier, but I’m not prepared to pay the huge costs of having a Motability vehicle for something that I wouldn’t choose in the open market. There are 3 more quarter changes before we need to think about it, so hopefully something might interest me by then.