If @Mike 700 took the UK ONS figures for his calculations they probably look bad.
Daf , I don’t recall quoting any figures, from any source, but if I did venture down that road, I would have done as I do now, ie. research several sources( archives), for example, Scottish Gov. UK Gov. and office for National statistics, Etc.,and extrapolate my own answer, not blindly copy someone else’s,?
Also, I am trying not to comment on political parties, other than offering some further reasons why I feel that one particular party & their supporters are leading the good people of Scotland ‘up the garden path’ over the true cost of Independence, and how these politician’s views are likely to hit the population where it really hurts – in the pocket?
There are clearly some very deep ‘black holes’ in the Independence economic presentations, which are being kept from the electorate .
I continue to quote as many facts as are available, rather than opinion, but I fully accept that others will have opposing views!