I see the Tiguan 2.0 Tsi has been added to the scheme l still have time to cancel my BMW X1 order and reorder the Tiguan should l ?
Hi George. Both are very good choices and it really boils down to what you want out of a car. I am very familiar with both cars and, in my opinion, the comparison between them (Tiguan Elegance 2.0i versus X1 xLine 20i is;
Tiguan scores over X1 – Quite a lot of extra equipment as standard (panoramic sunroof, keyless access, adaptive headlights, adaptive cruise, blind spot warning), 3” taller driving position, slightly more interior space, bigger boot capacity (floor area slightly bigger in X1 but Tiguan has more volume due to extra height).
X1 scores over Tiguan – Leather trim as standard, interior quality noticeably more premium, more car like handling, better auto (Tiguan has some lag), more refined engine, better mpg versus comparable Tiguan, iDrive ten times better than the dire Multimedia system VW uses, bigger fuel tank which with better mpg gives much better range.
In summary, if kit count and space are the most important factors, the Tiguan is the better bet (if leather isn’t needed). If a more driver orientated, refined and more premium feeling car that is also more fun to drive is preferred then it’s the X1. As I say, both are good choices so it boils down to which way you lean in these respects. Although the Tiguan has had a mild facelift, both cars are a bit dated now. An all new X1 is due next year and an all new Tiguan is probably a couple of years away.