Tough choice, ap on the BMW would be £650. Taking in account of GCB, and discount. I would pay for tinted rears at £300, and you have a stylish, well equipped car for under a £1000. Q2 is a small SUV, so a lot more versatile in that way. The bmw compares with the CLA and audi A3, more than the Q2. Or maybe an MB A class, which looks lovely but seems a tad expensive.